One good, one bad. And both taking place at the august Berlin Philharmonie, where I have practically taken up residence since arriving in Berlin two weeks ago.
The first was a performance by a group calling itself Il Pomo d’Oro, after a seventeenth-century Italian opera of that name. (It translates, literally, as “the golden apple.”) I knew nothing about them except that their performance in Berlin, which was officially sponsored by the Berlin Philharmonic, included a countertenor and a soprano as the singing voices on the program. This was enough to lure me in, though I figured it would be a minority taste.
Imagine my surprise, then, when I arrives at the Philharmonie on Monday night to find the whole large hall absolutely packed. I have no idea who these people were, except that I suspect many of them came from some other culture than the regular music-going Berlin audience. That is, they were extremely quiet and attentive during the music—wonderfully, magnetically so—but they insisted on applauding after every small break.
This was only a problem because the program had been carefully set up so as to resemble an almost religious occasion. The stage as well as the hall were darkened, with only minimal illumination that suggested cathedral-like candle lighting. From out of this darkness emerged six excellent musicians (two violins, a viola, a cello, a double bass, and an organ) playing some kind of Baroque tune, unidentifiable by me. Then, from the highest level on the lefthand side of the auditorium, came the eerie, beautiful sound of a human voice: the soprano, Madison Nonoa, singing what the program told me was a traditional Greek song. Then a bit more instrumental. And then, out of the darkness at on the right side of the stage, came the countertenor, Jakub Jósef Orlinski, eloquently singing Arvo Pärt’s “My Heart’s in the Highlands.” Finally, all the musicians, including the two singers, joined together at centerstage to perform the highlight of the evening, Pergolesi’s Stabat Mater. I know this beloved piece well, having heard several other live performances as well as numerous recordings, but I have never been present at a better, more stirring, more delicately nuanced version of it. The two voices—each outstanding on its own—became something even more remarkable when they twined together. I was in heaven for the duration of the concert, which only lasted 75 minutes or so, and which sent me home floating on air (almost literally so, since I got my favorite front-row seat on the upper level of bus M49).
Next up, three nights later, was a performance of the Berliner Philharmoniker itself. (For those confused by my terminology: the Berlin Philharmonie is the building in which the Berliner Philharmoniker—the resident orchestra itself—plays when it is at home. Other groups get to play there too, sometimes under the official auspices of the Philharmoniker and sometimes not. My transcendent RSB experience of last Sunday was one of the latter.) This was to be my second Philharmoniker concert of the trip, and since the program sounded lovely if highly tranditional—Mendelssohn, Mozart, Haydn—I looked forward to it, despite the fact that I had never heard of Maxim Emelyanychev, the visiting conductor.
Once again the hall was packed, though that was no surprise, with a crowd-pleasing program like this. The introductory Mendelssohn overture was fine if slight, and I withheld my judgment on the conductor: he threw himself around a bit too much for my taste, but it didn’t mess anything up. On the next piece, Mozart’s Concerto for Horn and Orchestra in E-Flat Major, he was thankfully tethered to the cembalo at the front of the orchestra, and the French-horn player—the absolutely terrific Yun Zeng, normally a regular member of the Philharmoniker—was able to shine gorgeously, not least in the jazzy encore he played.
But the second half of the program confirmed my niggling fears. Emelyanychev, who fancies himself a piano soloist as well as a conductor, took the solo part in the Haydn piano concerto (No. 11 in D Major) that opened that segment of the concert. Let me just say that I hope never to hear him play the piano again. He was not terrible (he was maybe as good as Barenboim had been at his worst), but in this age of stellar pianists like Yunchan Lim, Daniil Trifonov, Igor Levit, and Kirill Gerstein—the latter two of whom actually live right here in Berlin—it seems a waste to put a relative amateur onstage. So I was already irritated when the final piece on the program, Haydn’s “London” symphony, No. 104, began. And true to my worries, Emelyanychev was all over it. The piece cannot help but be exuberant—that is in its nature, and I love it for that—but to over-emphasize the brass, the drums, and the suspenseful pauses, as this conductor did, does the symphony no service. My own feeling about Haydn is that he needs to be treated with the utmost delicacy to avoid the potential oompah nature of some of his orchestral works. (The quartets need no such special care, though they can always benefit from it, as the marvelous Danish String Quartet has illustrated.) Emelyanychev was clearly not the man to do this. And though the Berliner Philharmoniker is incapable of giving a bad performance, last night’s concert was certainly not their finest hour.